|
Illness and Secrecy on the Supreme Court
PERSPECTIVE ~ New England Journal of Medicine, Vol. 351, No. 26, December 23, 2004, Susan Okie, M.D., pages 2675-2678.
Reviewed by Gary L. Wolfstone
Click here to Contact Mr. Wolfstone Seattle Trial Lawyer, garywolfstone@gmail.com
Susan Okie, M.D. is a Contributing Editor to the New England Journal of Medicine ("the Journal") based in Washington, D.C., and she has written a timely and thought provoking article concerning the recent illness and absence of Chief Justice William Rehnquist.
It was said of William James that he was a psychologist who wrote like a novelist, and Henry James was a novelist who wrote like a psychologist. My critique of Dr. Okie is that she is a physician who writes like and thinks like a journalist. People who write like and think like journalists ultimately fall into the trap of using the shibboleth that "the public has a right to know" ~ which is a dangerously intrusive standard when applied to the United States Supreme Court. I hasten to add that Dr. Okie did not dogmatically advocate that precise phrase in her article, but she does seem to lament the problem that "there is no formal mechanism for monitoring" the physical and mental competence of the Justices. [At 2676] She mentions that other federal judges are subject to the Judicial Conduct and Disability Act of 1980 while we are left to scrutinizing the "physical stamina and mental sharpness" of the Justices through lawyers, journalists and members of the public who observe the Justices' behavior during oral argument. [At 2676] Adopting the Socratic method, Dr. Okie asks the questions (just short of advocating the position) ~ does the public have the right to information about a Justice's medical diagnosis, treatment and condition and what measure can ensure the timely retirement of a Justice who is severely impaired by physical or mental illness? [At 2677]
Quoting a Supreme Court spokeswoman, Kathy Arberg, Dr. Okie remarks that the Court has an internal practice for dealing with such situations as the illness of the Justices. Apparently dissatisfied with the internal practice, however, Dr. Okie goes on to remind us of "an increasingly common strategy" of requiring confidential examinations by a forensic psychiatrist to assess the competence of sitting federal judges other than Supreme Court Justices. If the current Justices have already agreed upon that policy or a similar procedure, she concludes, then "they should share that decision with the American public." [At 2678]
True enough, the Supreme Court Justices have an internal system for persuading their fellow Justices to reconsider a position or to retire from the bench. This system is loose and informal, and the Justices do not march but instead they are likely to shift and shuttle and whine and wheedle in their decision making process, including the decision to prevail upon another Justice to leave the Court for poor health. This time honored internal decision-making process is properly shrouded in privacy, and only an outside critic would use the value laden term "secrecy" to characterize the system. Those of us who are admitted to practice before the U.S. Supreme Court still have faith, for the most part, in the wisdom of the founding fathers who gave the Justices lifetime tenure (during good behavior ~ the impeachment standard) in Article III of the U.S. Constitution. Outsiders, and specifically people who think and write like journalists, frequently suggest that the Justices should not be permitted to meander but rather should be required to march to the tune of a new statute or Constitutional Amendment. Informal "agreements" are only valid and binding during the lifetimes of the sitting Justices who had concurred in the informal agreement. There are no easy answers, but imposing structure upon the highest Court in our land is a temporary solution whose efficacy is more intuitive than demonstrable.
Since Louis Braille devised the first system of Braille and since the first book was published in Braille in 1827, precious few changes have been made to Braille. Of course, if my colleague Bill Gates owned Braille, we would see Braille 95, Braille 98, Braille 2000, Braille XP, et ainsi de suite, et ainsi de suite. If it's not broke, do we really need to fix it? S/he among you who says that it is broke, let her persuade the state legislatures to amend the Constitution.
Home |
Creative Projects |
Reference Library |
Contact Us
The Harvard Law School has historically influenced the United States Supreme Court more than any other institution.
Conf
Gary Woodlawn Ave
European Information Technology
Cat & Mouse
Cat Relax
Blow Kiss
Gary at Copa
Yliopisto
Green Lake
Eagle
Gary Harvard
Rosen Office
Kulta is an Angel
Switzerland
Bear Page
Avvo Welcome
Avvo Editorial
Seattle injury lawyer Gary Wolfstone
Seattle injury lawyer Gary Wolfstone
Mark Britton, former Avvo CEO
Gary Wolfstone
Gary Wolfstone
Zurich Harvard Club Member
Mark Britton
Mark Britton Explained
Mr. Wolfstone Bar Honors
Mark Britton
Gary Wolfstone
Mr. Wolfstone
Gary Wolfstone
Gary L. Wolfstone
Contact2
Contact3
Contact4
Write this down
Salmon-5
Life in the Fast Lane
Black Box 8
black_box7
Unafraid
Black Box 6
Acrobat on Greenlake
Is Gary Wolfstone an ethical lawyer?
Yes. Certainly. Ethical lawyer.
Gary near Redi
Gorse--On the Washington coast
Gary - Fifty Years WSBA
Gary - Truck Traffic
Kulta staff person
Kulta in Seattle
Bear Page
Avvo Welcome
Avvo Editorial
Jack Wolfstone
Kulta
Jackie
Kulta
Kulta in Snow
Kulta
Facing Puget Sund
ring
Big Van, Gary, Alice
Work"
Work
Graduation
Collision Ships with Map Index
Zuzu's petals - Wonderful Life
Salmon Logo with Menu
Winter - Helsinki - Pojois Esplanade
Gary - Kulta at Kamppi
Kulta at Med Cabinet
Payday
Repeat
Macavity the Cat
Two Colors
Frisky Bear in Living Room
Avvo Watch
Mountain
AvvoWatch stqtuse
First Page
Bear
Gary June 2008k
Swedish Bear on Grayland Hse Deck
See Elvi At Wprk (click here)
Resignation
Russian Economy
Making Rules
Bear Page
Avvo Welcome
Avvo Editorial
Gary Wolfstone
Gary Face
Policy Limits
Many Thanks, clients and friends
Consulting Officer
Tulips
Gary & Jackie
Begin-next
pc-lawyer book
Bench
Waterfront statue
Gary-Keskus
Default Eagle NEW
DEFAULT DILIGENCE
JOHN HARVARD STATUE
GIRLS SO SILLY
Gary Alki
Gary with Santa Doll
Holiday
Home-Red-Logo
Scroll_Testify
2020-900
Home-Sydam-Home
Just-Us-733
Home-SUV3-Home
Fees on Referral
More Fees on Referral
Repeat Business
Laid Off Tech
Samoin
Again
Kulta
Louise, Chuck, Gary
Louise, Charles, Gary
Big Van, Gary, Alice
Van, Gary, Chuck
Ron and Alice, Iowa, Wedding
Honor
Alycia was May Day Queen
Homeless
Bogart
Admissability-Opinions
Hortensia
Honor
1 - Sabbatical Leave
2 - Life in Fast Lane Bridge
3 - Selena's Devoted Fan
Cat Alley Condo, Seattle
Suzy loon Bear Face
Jeff Burns at Work
Beach Hse Painting 3
Beach Hse Painting 2
Beach Hse Painting 1
Ships Colliding
Gary and Kulta
Submit Your Resume
Gary Only Smiling
Blue Angels
Gary Ask for More Old
Kulta Red Tulips
Protest
Is Gary Wolfstone an ethical lawyer?
Yes. Certainly. Ethical lawyer.
Gary near Redi
Gorse--On the Washington coast
Gary - Fifty Years WSBA
Gary - Truck Traffic
Kulta staff person
Collision Ships with Map Index
Zuzu's petals - Wonderful Life
Salmon Logo with Menu
Winter - Helsinki - Pojois Esplanade
Gary - Kulta at Kamppi
Kulta at Med Cabinet
Payday
Repeat
Macavity the Cat
Two Colors
Frisky Bear in Living Room
Avvo Watch
Mountain
AvvoWatch stqtuse
First Page
Bear
Gary June 2008k
Swedish Bear on Grayland Hse Deck
See Elvi At Wprk (click here)
Resignation
Russian Economy
Gary Wolfstone
Gary Face
Policy Limits
Many Thanks, clients and friends
Consulting Officer
Tulips
Gary & Jackie
Begin-next
pc-lawyer book
Bench
Waterfront statue
Gary-Keskus
Default Eagle NEW
DEFAULT DILIGENCE
JOHN HARVARD STATUE
GIRLS SO SILLY
Gary Alki
Gary with Santa Doll
Holiday
Home-Red-Logo
Scroll_Testify
2020-900
Home-Sydam-Home
Just-Us-733
Home-SUV3-Home
Fees on Referral
More Fees on Referral
Repeat Business
Laid Off Tech
Samoin
Again
Kulta
Louise, Chuck, Gary
Louise, Charles, Gary
Big Van, Gary, Alice
Van, Gary, Chuck
Ron and Alice, Iowa, Wedding
Honor
Alycia was May Day Queen
Homeless
Bogart
Admissability-Opinions
Hortensia
Honor
1 - Sabbatical Leave
2 - Life in Fast Lane Bridge
3 - Selena's Devoted Fan
Cat Alley Condo, Seattle
Suzy loon Bear Face
Jeff Burns at Work
Beach Hse Painting 3
Beach Hse Painting 2
Beach Hse Painting 1
Ships Colliding
Gary and Kulta
Submit Your Resume
Gary Only Smiling
Blue Angels
Gary Ask for More Old
Kulta Red Tulips
Protest
Homeless
Bogart
Admissability-Opinions
Hortensia
Honor
1 - Sabbatical Leave
2 - Life in Fast Lane Bridge
3 - Selena's Devoted Fan
Cat Alley Condo, Seattle
Suzy loon Bear Face
Jeff Burns at Work
Beach Hse Painting 3
Beach Hse Painting 2
Beach Hse Painting 1
Ships Colliding
Gary and Kulta
Submit Your Resume
Gary Only Smiling
Blue Angels
Gary Ask for More Old
Kulta Red Tulips
Protest
Jeff Burns at Work
Beach Hse Painting 3
Beach Hse Painting 2
Beach Hse Painting 1
Ships Colliding
Gary and Kulta
Submit Your Resume
Gary Only Smiling
Blue Angels
Gary Ask for More Old
Kulta Red Tulips
Protest
Moving-Be Safe-Be Well
Jeff Burns at Work
Beach Hse Painting 3
Beach Hse Painting 2
Beach Hse Painting 1
Ships Colliding
Gary and Kulta
Submit Your Resume
Gary Only Smiling
Blue Angels
Gary Ask for More Old
Kulta Red Tulips
Protest
Flag, Gavel, Home
Remember WTCr
Small mars rover
snow new
SR71
Country Codes Telephonic 1991
Rainbow Charters 1991
Pot Shed, Rainbow Charters
Thanksgiving
Htm Home
Mountain
More Kinder
Yet More Kinder
Alot of Kinder
Kinder5
Himself
More Kinder
Yet More Kinder
Alot of Kinder
Kinder5
Keesler AFB 2
Kinder
Just Us Justice
s y d a m
Resume - A Summary
Wallingford House 3932
Water Fall 3
Water Fall 2
Remember World Trade Center
Water Fall 2
Remember World Trade Center
X Y Z PARDON
Yonder Bear
Wrongful Death
Bear with Swedish Flag
Theatrical with kids
Downtown Park
Tulips
Bio_liberty
Areas Bridge
Default xPeak
Winter
Wolfstone-again
Menu with GLW Photo
Gary Wolfstone Ethics
Adjuster Eclipse You
City Hall
KerryPark Gary Kulta
Welcome (2014) 2024
Scroll Testify
Scroll Repeat
Talvi Eight
NEW TESTIFY
transom
Cat-Mouse-Game
Jenna large
scroll 2
scroll
Jenna narrow
We Watch Over Our Clients
One of A Kind
weekend
Whitman-1969-Memories
2025 Sign
default wet sand
default wonderful
Cease fire
Got You Covered
White Rose
Wolfstone-new
default blue
pc-lawyer
Satisfied Customers
Wolfstone Cares Deeply About Ethics
Ethical Lawyer Running
Zebra Menu
Menu of Other Stations
Various Positions
St. Patrick's Day
Diversity
Fubar
Commit
No Fusion
ZigZag
Judge
Wake.html
monica.html
xyz.html
50.html
60.html
tiger.html
resume-2.html
greencard.html
January2024
Feb2024
March2024
Agents Literary
Yonder Bear
Home-Page
50 Year Letter
xmas 2003
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
More Moon Shine
Seattle personal injury lawyer
Seattle injury lawyer
Seattle personal injury lawyer-repeatr
Seattle injury lawyer
Life Fast Lane
Menu of Other Stations
Various Positions
St. Patrick's Day
Diversity
Fubar
Commit
No Fusion
ZigZag
Judge
Wake.html
monica.html
xyz.html
50.html
60.html
tiger.html
resume-2.html
greencard.html
January2024
Feb2024
March2024
Agents Literary
Yonder Bear
Home-Page
50 Year Letter
xmas 2003
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
More Moon Shine
Seattle personal injury lawyer
Seattle injury lawyer
Seattle personal injury lawyer-repeatr
Seattle injury lawyer
Life Fast Lane
Road Kill
Alakoske
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Glory Top Hat One
Glory Top Hat Two
Glory Top Hat Three
Glory Original Blond One
Glory Original Blond Two
Glory Original Blond Three
Lightning-to-Mark-Britton
Folklife
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
Seattle View
Post Surgery
Define IS
Kulta More
ABAB
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Glory Top Hat One
Glory Top Hat Two
Glory Top Hat Three
Glory Original Blond One
Glory Original Blond Two
Glory Original Blond Three
Lightning-to-Mark-Britton
Folklife
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
Seattle View
Post Surgery
Agents Literary
Tower
Post Surgery
Agents Literary
Tower
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
Agents Literary
Tower
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
More Moon Shine
Seattle personal injury lawyer
Seattle injury lawyer
Patriot
Seattle View
Post Surgery
Agents Literary
Tower
Home-Page
Agents Literary
Tower
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
More Moon Shine
Seattle personal injury lawyer
Seattle injury lawyer
Seattle personal injury lawyer-repeatr
Seattle injury lawyer
Profile Avvowatch Profile
Britton's Blood Libel
Pot Shed, Rainbow Charters
ABAB
Broken Arrow
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Folklife
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
Alycia & Daisy at Shilshoe
Mark Extra
Our Profile Page
Road Kill
ABAB
Broken Arrow
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Folklife
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
Road Kill
ABAB
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Glory Top Hat One
Glory Top Hat Two
Glory Top Hat Three
Glory Original Blond One
Glory Original Blond Two
Glory Original Blond Three
Lightning-to-Mark-Britton
Folklife
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
Seattle View
Post Surgery
Agents Literary
Tower
Road Kill
ABAB
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Glory Top Hat One
Glory Top Hat Two
Glory Top Hat Three
Glory Original Blond One
Glory Original Blond Two
Glory Original Blond Three
Lightning-to-Mark-Britton
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
world800class
ABAB
Bio-old
Blow Kiss
Making Rules
Moonshine
Mtn Shadows
US Flag
Wonderful Life
Waterfall
Ships ISMAP
Flag and Gavel
Think Incorporation
Panda3
Panda2
The Deposition
Natasha
More Natasha
Lorena
First Blog
Black Box
Black Box 3
Black Box 5
Glory Top Hat One
Glory Top Hat Two
Glory Top Hat Three
Glory Original Blond One
Glory Original Blond Two
Glory Original Blond Three
Lightning-to-Mark-Britton
Folklife
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Gary to Mark
Gary Office
Big Winter
Helsinki-December-scene
Mark Britton Editorial
Mark Britton Libel
US Supreme Court Docket
Meet Mr. Britton
Index Salmon
Laid Off Tech
Rosie
zebra2
Titanic
zebra_2
Home-Page
Agents Literary
Tower
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
More Moon Shine
Seattle personal injury lawyer
Seattle injury lawyer
Patriot
Seattle View
Post Surgery
Agents Literary
Tower
Home-Page
Agents Literary
Tower
Default Ships
More Moon Shine
More Moon Shine
Seattle personal injury lawyer
Seattle injury lawyer
Seattle personal injury lawyer-repeatr
Seattle injury lawyer
Profile Avvowatch Profile
Britton's Blood Libel
|